Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Love Crime


Alain Corneau’s Love Crime is one hell of an ingeniously crafted French thriller. The film tells the story of the affable, and borderline psychosexual, relationship between Christine (Kristen Scott Thomas) a top-level business executive, and her dedicated protégé, Isabelle (Ludivine Sagnier). At the start of the film, Isabelle reverently hinges on Christine’s every word, doing what she’s told and doing it well.

We’re roughly 15 minutes in before things start to go a little mad.

Because Isabelle is apparently too good at her job, Christine decides to start fucking with her, just for kicks. She humilities her professionally in front of respected clients, privately in front of the casual lover they both share, and publicly at employee parties. It’s never made fully clear as to why Christine is doing what she’s doing. As played with expert precision by Scott Thomas, Christine is openly regarded as a cold-hearted bitch by those who know her, but her honed-in scare tactics against Isabelle are wildly without merit. She’s like Meryl Streep’s character in The Devil Wears Prada, laced with venom.
Now, most of us have seen this film before. The employer-employee feud that ultimately ends with one of them ousting the other and raising their hands in victory. But Love Crime is no Working Girl. Point in fact, after the plot is set and the characters are firmly established, the film dives into an extended sequence of seemingly pointless planning.

To explain, when we get the sense that Isabelle has (finally) had enough, she starts to roam around her spotless apartment in a haze; popping pills, stemming roses, going to the movies, whatever. In short, she seems to be planning something, but with half-assed purpose, and we have no idea why, or to what avail. When Love Crime was released theatrically last year, most of the reviews I saw were moderate to negative, which reflects the shared frustration that critics must have felt from being left in the dark during this sequence.

I too felt detached, but when things start to click into place (and believe me, do they ever), Love Crime evolves into a splendid little thriller that’s never too smart for its own good. I’ve described roughly the first 50 minutes of the film, and I won’t dare continue. Just know that it is rather difficult for a film to trick me (which Love Crime did), and if I catch on to some of those tricks (which I did, in part), then it is very difficult for me to finish the film feeling satisfied. And to say I felt satisfaction when Love Crime’s final credits rolled is seriously understating my stance.
In a fantastic bit of Hollywood planning, Brian De Palma has signed on to direct Passion, an American remake of Love Crime. Noomi Rapace is set to star, with Rachel McAdams possibly filling out the other role. I’ll be curious as to which actress takes which role, given that they are one year apart in age (Scott Thomas is 19 years Sagnier’s senior). At any rate, you can wait for De Palma’s version (which shoots this summer), or catch Corneau’s very worthy thriller on Netflix Instant now. 

Love Crime is most definitely worthy, but I somehow think De Palma’s vision will improve upon the material. And really, when was the last time you felt pleased that an accomplished foreign film was getting an American treatment? B+

13 comments:

  1. Good review! Happy to see this is worth-watching. Will have to check this out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Ty Thanks man! I enjoyed it much more than I thought I would.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm generally highly against American remakes of foreign films, but in this case, I think you may be right. I really enjoyed Love Crime (and I'm not sure Rapace and McAdams, if it turns out to be McAdams, can pull off the icy coolness that Scott Thomas and Sagnier did), but the one complaint I had about it was how flatly it was shot. It has all the plotting and characters of a Hitchcock thriller, but without any of Hitchcock's visual flair. DePalma could quite easily fix that. On the other hand, DePalma has a tendency to go TOO flamboyant, and I haven't liked a whole lot of what he's done recently. I'm definitely curious, though.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @Jandy Wow, all seriously great thoughts. I too agree that there was nothing special about Love Crime's look, and I also think that is one of the aspects De Palma could improve upon, if, yes, he doesn't go too De Palma with it.

    I'll definitely be curious to see who they cast. Am I crazy, but what's wrong with Rapace in the young role and... Scott Thomas reprising her role?

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Jandy Also, thanks for stopping by! You have some great opinions about what the new Love Crime could be.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Alex, I could definitely see that casting working quite well! Rapace could pull off the Sagnier character quite well, no question. I'd be more worried about McAdams - nothing against her, but she's not really calculating enough for either role, I don't think. And Scott Thomas certainly speaks English well enough. :p

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Jandy Again, completely agree. I love McAdams, but yeah, I don't think she could effectively pull off either role. I know Rapace is definitely attached and McAdams is just rumored at this point, but who knows, maybe she'll blow us away...

    ReplyDelete
  8. This sounds fantastic, if only because of Kristin Scott Thomas - a phenomenal actor who I find it so bizarre still seems under recognised by general audiences.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Andrew: Encore Entertainment Oh I totally agree. This, Tell No One, Sarah's Key, Gosford Park, English Patient and especially I've Loved You So Long... she's fantastic in all of them.

    Thanks for stopping by!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Must watch KST films:
      A HANDFUL OF DUST
      BITTER MOON
      rounded out by
      THE VALET
      GOSFORD PARK
      ANGELS & INSECTS

      Delete
    2. All excellent choices. And I've Loved You So Long... she was remarkable in that one.

      Delete
  10. Great review! I'm going to see this movie this week and I can't wait to see what De Palma does!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you'll really dig this one. I'd De Palma does it right, it'll be a real return to form. Can't wait.

      Delete