Thursday, February 20, 2014

Top 5 Matthew McConaughey Performances (before 2011)

If anyone was to compile of list of Matthew McConaughey’s finest performances, I’m safe in assuming that the majority of the films on that list would have been released after 2011. In 2009, McConaughey decided to take two years off to transform his career, ultimately coming back to the scene with a vengeance. Today, he’s an Oscar front-runner for Best Actor and the most intriguing character on television (via HBO’s True Detective), just to name two feats of many.

So, far a bit of a change, I thought it’d be interesting to list my favorite McConaughey performances prior to his self-imposed career resurgence. Be sure to share yours as well!

5. Tropic Thunder (2008)
as Rick Peck

I remember watching McConaughey ham it up as a hyperbolic Hollywood agent in Tropic Thunder and thinking, “Jesus, this guy really does have something… when he wants to.” Before his role as Rick Peck, I honestly hadn’t enjoyed a McConaughey performance in several years, but Tropic Thunder was a perfect (if not frustrating) reminder that McConaughey had that thing, that spark… that desire to deliver.

4. Thirteen Conversations About One Thing (2001)
as Troy
The criminally underseen Thirteen Conversations About One Thing is one of those films with a disjointed narrative in which every major character is somehow connected. At the film’s core is Troy, a hotshit district attorney whose life is altered after he commits a hit and run. We’re never sure why Troy drove away from the accident – could be he had too much to drink at happy hour, or pride, or fear, or all of the above – but it’s quite thrilling to watch Troy implode in anguish as he tries to determine his own fate.

3. Frailty (2001)
as Fenton Meiks
I kind of love Bill Paxton’s Frailty. It’s some sort of Southern gothic/horror/fantasy hybrid that always feels a little off. The movie is told in flashback from the perspective of Fenton Meiks, a troubled man who believes that his brother is a serial killer. But as we watch Fenton’s narrative unfold, we always suspect that details are being withheld. Fenton is an unreliable narrator, because he chooses to be. The result is a patient, quietly disturbing portrayal of a man who may or may not be completely fucking mad.

2. A Time to Kill (1996)
as Jake Brigance
Okay, so… I kind of love Joel Schumacher’s A Time to Kill, too. Appreciate is probably a better word than love, but the point is, I think it’s a honest and heartfelt examination of race in America, anchored by McConaughey’s strong performance as a naïve attorney. Whether he’s whaling violently for his dog to return home, or delivering a patient, gut wrenching closing argument, there’s really nothing about this performance that doesn’t work for me.

1. Dazed and Confused (1993)
as Wooderson
Matthew McConaughey’s work as infamous townie David Wooderson is the definition of a star making performance. Every word is delivered to comic perfection, every strut is timed effortlessly, every movement is confident – it’s that beautiful, rare encounter of an actor being literally born to play a role.

And there’s the thing: Matthew McConaughey wasn’t even an actor when he was cast in this movie. As Richard Linklater was trying to find actors to flesh out the characters in his film, the producer of Dazed stumbled across McConaughey in a bar, and casually asked him if he wanted to play this Wooderson guy. At that point, Wooderson only had one scene and a handful of lines, but as filming progressed, Linklater had the foresight to see that he had tapped into pure gold in the form of Matthew McConaughey. The result is one of my all time favorite film characters – ceaselessly funny, forever iconic. All right, all right, all right.

42 comments:

  1. Ah, never a doubt in my mind what would occupy the top spot here. Dazed is exactly what you said, a star making role if there ever was one, and a role that I don't think McConaughey had been cast as perfectly in until his role in Mud. I also completely agree with your sentiments on Tropic Thunder (The Pecker is on a TiVo mission for Y O U). I remember seeing Frailty a while back (before McConaughey's resurgence) and being really surprised by how good he was in that role. Need to check out the other two on this list though. I probably would have put his role in Lone Star as well, but I got no qualms with this list man! Good on you for ruling out everything he's done since 2011 - not enough people look back on most of these films.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you like the list! Lone Star would come in at an easy number 6; love him in that. I rewatched it a few weeks ago and am slightly more taken with the 5 I listed.

      I love what you said about his casting in Mud. That just seemed so appropriate, surely like he was born to be in that movie at that time.

      Delete
  2. Alright, alright, alright... it amazes me at how far he's come ever since he took a break and decided not to be the surfer guy, the stoner guy, and the guy who ends up looking like a cardboard guy. It's clear that he was talented before he decided to make some changes and get really serious. Still, there are performances that are just amazing to showcase how good he was.

    1. Wooderson in Dazed & Confused
    2. Buddy Deeds in Lone Star
    3. Rick Peck in Tropic Thunder (my client wants a TiVo! My client gets the TiVo!!!!)
    4. Jake Tyler Brigance in A Time to Kill
    5. Lt. Tyler in U-571

    Even the rom-coms he did weren't so bad but it had him be very mechanical and uninspired. Ghosts of Girlfriends Past (where Emma Stone stole the film from him), Fool's Gold, and Failure to Launch were low-points as even Surfer Dude w/ the premise itself being promising showcase how bad things had gotten.

    I think it was his first appearance in Eastbound & Down is what began what would become the McConnaissance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nice list. I agree that his romcoms really weren't that bad. But man, the balls it took him to take time off and totally redefine his career is so incredible. I LOVE his work on Eastbound & Down. He was great in that.

      Delete
  3. Ditto the Lone Star citations, but then again I haven't seen 13 Conversations and don't remember much about Frailty from when I last saw it. The guy really has proven second chances are possible. Just a couple years ago, I had written him off entirely as a lost cause.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same here man. But yep, second chances really can happen, just takes patience and a lot of courage. I highly recommend 13 Convos.

      Delete
  4. OK, this may sound a little weird but I think he was really excellent in Reign of Fire. He plays a serious bad ass, and commits to the insanity of the character.Christian Bale disappears when McConaughey is on screen. That is not easy to do. There are a whole bunch of scenery chewing opportunities that he takes up to the edge but never indulges to the point of caricature.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey man, we like what we like! Plus, I actually kind of dig that flick. It's perfectly content being exactly what it is, if that makes sense. He's solid in it.

      Delete
  5. Oh I love this post! i have never seen Thirteen Conversations About One Thing but I need to now, also he plays someone involved in legal system there too? What the hell is up with Hollywood, real lawyers don't look like that, if they did I'd run to work with a smile on my face each day.

    He is so awesome in Tropic Thunder - 'You don't need to explain to me why you need TiVo... or clean water. Clean sheets. Food. Shelter.' :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! Ha, I love how movies make most everyone look incredibly gorgeous. So silly.

      Gotta love The Pecker!

      Delete
  6. Great post, I never realised he had so many excellent performances. Of late he has starred in some great roles that have changed many people's opinions on him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks man. He's definitely killing it as of late.

      Delete
  7. Nice post! You're so right about the "before 2011" part. I think his best prior to that was Frailty. He was always good in any part where he had to play a lawyer. He's a pretty convincing once. I love that scene in Tropic Thunder when he's like "Kids are great, at least you get to pick yours." and the camera pans to that photo of him and his fat son. That was hilarious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! He's such a creep in Frailty... really solid work.

      I LOVE that line in Tropic Thunder. And how it cuts to a small picture of him and his son. Haha, jesus.

      Delete
  8. Great list, man! No doubt that Wooderson should be at the top. However, based on the performances on this list, I never would've thought that he would end up on my best list... ever.

    True Detective is currently blowing my pants off! Last week was just amazing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks buddy! True Detective is one of the best TV shows I've ever seen. Really, it's quite a revelation, and he is sensational in it.

      Delete
  9. Excellent list. Somehow I still haven't seen "Dazed and Confused." I need to check that out. Given that bit of info it's probably no surprise I would go with "A Time to Kill" as my #1. I also thought he was excellent in the underrated (to me, at least) "Two for the Money."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! You gotta see Dazed, man. So iconic. I kind of dig Two for the Money in a sleazy sort of way. Not half bad at all.

      Delete
  10. Great list! He'so good in Tropic Thunder. I think that role was originally supposed to be for Owen Wilson.

    It's funny you mention him being an unreliable narrator in Frailty because that's exactly how I think of him in True Detective. Interesting parallel.

    It's so crazy that he was discovered in a bar and now he's Oscar nominated.

    I really enjoy him in Contact although I know that's probably not one of his best performances. You could see he had talent even then though. I also wish his franchise attempt with Sahara had worked. Would be cool to see him reprise Dirk Pitt again now that he's a big shot. I've seen some squabble about him being a good fit for Marvel's Doctor Strange but I don't think he's right for that role.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Robert! You're right about Owen in TT. But after he tried to kill himself, Stiller offered the role to Matt Mc. God, that was such a sad thing when that happened.

      I like his work in Contact as well. He isn't great, but you can tell he's capable of greatness.

      Delete
  11. Frailty gets my vote for his best pre-2011 performance. Oh, and Lone Star deserves a mention as well. (In my eyes, his best work period is in Killer Joe.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I recently said his best work was Dallas Buyers, but I'm going back with Killer Joe as well. Lone Star would come in at an easy number 6; love him in that. I rewatched it a few weeks ago and am slightly more taken with the 5 I listed.

      Delete
  12. Not to pile on, but I'd have had Lone Star on here, too, and at or near the top.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lone Star would come in at an easy number 6; love him in that. I rewatched it a few weeks ago and am slightly more taken with the 5 I listed.

      Delete
  13. Figured it would be Dazed! Nice. This guy is on a god damn roll lately. He's like a fine wine, he just gets better with age. Mud, Dallas Buyers Club, True Detective etc.. On fire!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hell yeah man, totally on fire. Are you a True Detective fan? I love that damn show.

      Delete
  14. Love the spirit behind this list. I've seen it put forth in recent weeks that The McConnaissance isn't actually a thing because he was never a great actor, or some such, to begin with. And while his roles, I don't think, were ever at the level they are now, as your list demonstrates, you could always SEE the spark. You could!

    I won't argue but I'd say "Lone Star" would be my personal #1. That was when I remember sitting up and going, "Woah..... His charisma is real."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks man, really glad you got what I was going for with the list.

      And yeah, just to reiterate, I LOVE his work in Lone Star. It really came down to that and Tropic Thunder, and TT is his best post-Dazed/pre-Bernie comedic performance, so I thought it deserved mention here.

      Delete
  15. I was immediately thinking of Frailty. An underrated horror film from a director who is similarly underrated. McConaughey is definitely producing some of his most dynamic work of late though, however, I did enjoy him in EdTV.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you're a Frailty fan. I really like that movie, and I agree, it is vastly underrated. I haven't seen EdTV in years. I'm sure it'd be fun to compare his interactions with Woody Harrelson in that film vs. True Detective.

      Delete
  16. Man, I've been meaning to watch Dazed and Confused and Frailty for a long time, and I really must watch Thirteen Conversations! So glad to see A Time to Kill at #2. That might be favorite McConaughey performance, period. He was fantastic and just misses my Best Actor lineup that year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I forgot you were such a fan of A Time to Kill - that really is an underrated and incredible little film. I value it, and Matt Mc's work in it, so much.

      Delete
  17. Nice pick with Thirteen Conversations about One Thing. I remember really liking that movie when it came out in the theaters, and his part is one of the stronger ones. It's totally slipped into the background. Frailty is another inspired choice; it's so chilling and paced deliberately to raise the tension as we go along.

    No EdTV? (:

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dan, glad to hear you're a Thirteen Conversations fan. That one really did fade away, which is such a shame.

      I really do need to give EdTV a rewatch!

      Delete
  18. For me.. How to Loose a Guy in 10 Days was probably where I was like, who is that man!? So it kind of remains as one of my favorite performances of him.. if I think about it, if it wasn't a rom com and the plot was a bit different, his delivered his lines with some great skill.. or maybe I'm just so used to him in amazing roles that I'm imagining his older ones into better ones. :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll be the first to admit that while I don't like most romcoms, he definitely fit well into that world. He's always been able to sell that material really well. The other day, Failure to Launch was on TV and I watched for a few minutes and yeah, he was okay in it. But I ALWAYS felt like there was more to him. Which is why I'm so happy his career is where it is now.

      Delete
  19. I've never seen Dazed and Confused, and I am loving that screenshot of a very young, goofy McConaughey. I hated Tropic Thunder, but I remember his performance as being a rare bright spot. I read A Time to Kill and remember it is being one of the best of Grisham's novels. I never felt an urge to see the film adaptation, partly because it was such a tough story, but maybe I'll give it a go. I'm unfamiliar with these other movies, but you have piqued my interest in 13 Conversations. Maybe I'll add it to my queue.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh god, you would love Dazed and Confused. That movie is such a portrait of that time period. So genuine and authentic. And he is hilarious in it.

      I also think you'd appreciate 13 Conversations. A lot of troubling moral dilemmas posed in that movie.

      Delete
  20. Lone Star? Contact? Amistad? The Newton Boys? EDtv? U-571? We Are Marshall?

    ReplyDelete
  21. He made one of the greatest comebacks in acting. EVER. I saw once Ghosts of Girlfriends Past. Oh my God, was awful. I hated every second of my time spend with it. I was like 'wtf is with this guy?'. If you'd ask me, a few years back, if I want to watch a Matthew McConaughey film I would laugh in your face. Then I saw The Lincoln Lawyer and I though 'I think this guy can do better'. Now, I can't wait to see the next Matthew McConaughey film. It is fantastic. This give me hope that a bad actor can become again a good actor. My favorite performance of him IS Interstellar. He just sells me that he is a father that wants to save his daughter and the humanity.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really respect someone who takes some time off and comes back with a full career reinvention. He always had talent, in my eye, he just rarely chose the right material to exploit that talent. Glad he's killing it now though. My favorite performance of his is True Detective.

      Delete